< All Shows

The Secondhand Movie

May 1, 2026 7:30 PM

Event Description:

An improvised recreation of a movie almost nobody's seen.
Hosted by movie super nerd Nick Carrillo. A special guest is tasked with the homework of watching an obscure movie in the 'so bad it's good' genre. On the night of the show the guest will do their best to retell the plot of the movie to a cast of improvisers and the live audience. The improvisers then recreate the story as told by the guest... It's like a game of telephone but with a movie- it's The Secondhand Movie!

About Grove 34

  • 🎟️ All tickets are general admission. Seating is first come first serve. Doors typically open 15 mins prior to show time.  **The show starts at the time listed. If you are not at the venue by the start of the show, we may release your tickets to the waitlist**
  • 🚇 N, W Trains to the Broadway stop. Alternate R, M to Steinway.
  • 🚗 Street Parking is available. Best meter spot (free after 7pm) on Broadway or 31st ST
  • 💵 Refunds only available more than 7 days prior to show.
  • ♿ Grove 34 is wheelchair accessible. THAT ONE GOOGLE REVIEW WAS BEFORE WE GOT A RAMP!
  • 🍺 Our bar serves beer, wine and alcohalic seltzers as well as several non-a drinks. BYOB is allowed with a $20 corking fee.  
  • 🎥 Video recording of any kind is prohibited without the express permission of the performer. Photography is encouraged and feel free to tag us 😉

Event Description:

An improvised recreation of a movie almost nobody's seen.
Hosted by movie super nerd Nick Carrillo. A special guest is tasked with the homework of watching an obscure movie in the 'so bad it's good' genre. On the night of the show the guest will do their best to retell the plot of the movie to a cast of improvisers and the live audience. The improvisers then recreate the story as told by the guest... It's like a game of telephone but with a movie- it's The Secondhand Movie!